best tightline eyeliner

Tightlining your eyeliner works wonders to make your eyes look bigger and your lashes appear longer and thicker. Maybelline Makeup Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eye Liner, Blackest Black, Waterproof, 0.106 oz; Revlon ColorStay Exactify Liquid Liner, Intense Black; … Black Opal COLORSPLURGE Precision Eye Definer, Best Waterproof: But let’s face it: Whether you’re going for a sharp wing, grunge look, or trendy graphic lines, the options are overwhelming. Three, rich pigment is a must. CoverGirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner ($6.99) This formula is on the stiffer side, but still does not take much pressure to … We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links. Even better, it’s super gentle and won’t irritate even the most sensitive eyes. Maybelline New York Unstoppable Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil, Best White: All eyeliners aren’t created equally and lining your waterline with the wrong type can be a disaster. While lining the inner rims of your eyes, a.k.a., the waterline, might sound tricky, using the right tools is the key to success. Created by celebrity makeup artist Jillian Dempsey, this kohl pencil is arguably one of the best waterline eyeliners. Because this richly-pigmented eyeliner is a pencil, you'll have plenty of control during application, but the formula isn't dry like other pencils. https://www.stylecraze.com/articles/best-eyeliners-for-tightlining Yeah, sure, you can use it to rim your waterlines, but it also plays a key role in crafting a smokey eye and making your lashes look fuller. There is no reason to put yourself in the red zone over an expensive eyeliner. Best Overall: This one trusty liner can take your look from subtle to bold all on its own. The surprisingly creamy consistency (it’s not actually gel-like at all) paints lids with a smooth and even trace, not leaving a skid or skip on lines. Gel eyeliners might look intimidating (maybe it has something to do with using a separate brush to apply), but in reality, they’re super easy to use and often recommended for eyeliner beginners. It doesn’t move around when you’re trying to really deposit the product. Two, blending is important, but it also has to be powerful enough to stay put. For the best tightlining effect, make sure to only collect a small amount of pigment on your brush before applying eyeliner. Rimmel Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer, Best Shimmer: If you're looking for value, this smudge-proof liner is your best bet. 5 Best Drugstore Eyeliner for Tightlining Reviews. This mechanical pencil dispenses a rich, creamy color that doesn’t flake or fade throughout the day. In case you didn’t know, waterline eyeliner, aka tightline eyeliner is used in a technique that allows you to enhance the look of your eyes. Tightlining, also known as invisible eyeliner, is one of our favorite techniques for subtly enhancing your makeup look.With just a swipe of eyeliner along your upper waterline, your lashes instantly appear … # Preview Product Price; 1: ... MEXI Makeup Waterproof Leopard Shell Liquid Eye Liner Eyeliner Pen Cosmetic. You don't have to spend a ton to get an awesome beauty product you'll obsess over. review process here. The reason is that the liner manages to both stay put and not irritate people’s eyes … Smudge-proof and long-wearing, this pencil glides on smoothly, says Thompson. When choosing a drugstore eyeliner, it's important to consider how precise you want your lines to be, if you want to smudge or smoke out your liner, and whether or not you need a waterproof formula. At the time of publishing, we were not able to find enough drugstore eyeliners from Black-owned and/or Black-founded businesses to meet this percentage. hours, is the gold-standard. Though potted, or gel, eyeliners take some practice to master, they are extremely versatile and offer intense pigment. We thought so too until we discovered this budget-friendly option from L’Oreal. Read on for the best drugstore eyeliners. Expressionist Liquid Eyeliner from W3ll People Cruelty-free, vegan, gluten-free This liquid liner comes with a firm felt tip, so you won’t have to worry about accidentally flicking your eyeliner … Tightline is a programming technique which can allow you to attain the delicate definition of your own eyes with no necessity for eyeliner. This felt tip eyeliner has built a strong cult following and with good reason—the combination of its precise felt tip, true black ink, and versatility has proved itself to be simply unbeatable when it comes to drugstore eyeliners. Now you can put away your protractor (and that awkward clawish grip) and count on this ergonomic tool for fool-proof application. While every liner on the list is an excellent choice, the best eyeliner for tightlining is L’Oreal Paris’ Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner. M.A.C, an industry leader in pro-quality cosmetics that delight consumers and professional makeup artists alike, rarely disappoints, and the M.A.C Cosmetics Pro Longwear Eye Liner … The gel pot comes with a thin pointed brush that we love because a) it makes the long-wearing formula glide on like butter, and b) there’s no need to shell out cash on another item. Since her years as an editorial intern, Arielle has worked on staff and freelanced for multiple publications including Marie Claire, Good Housekeeping, and People. “I love Master Precise Skinny Pencil eyeliner," says makeup artist Erin Ayanian Monroe. If you’ve ever had to go to work the morning after a late-night, you can understand that barely-there, bloodshot look. To help separate the good from the bad, we asked makeup artists to recommend the best drugstore eyeliners available. You don’t want to use just any eyeliner pen or pencil — a liner that suits a cat-eye, for example, might not be best for tightlining… One swipe and you’re done. Tightlining—or drawing the liner on the water line—is a great way to make hooded or drooping eyes look fuller, but if you use the wrong product, you'll end up with raccoon eyes by day's end. "This liner is a must-have staple in my kit," says Kelly Coulter, a professional makeup artist. We have different types of eyeliners to cater to our eye makeup needs, and liquid is the best option for me, with pencil running at a close second. “For the ultimate cat eye, this is my go-to every time," says makeup artist Desirae Cherman. Shop them all, ahead. Whether you love making your eyes look bigger or sporting thicker-looking lashes, applying eyeliner to your waterline can make it happen. This inexpensive liner has an amazing charcoal black color that's hard to find, says Kelly Thompson, a makeup artist in NYC. Now, if you want to have the best eyeliner for tightlining, there is a need for you to choose the right formula. That’s why we suggest going for this waterproof option for the person that likes to be prepared at all times. Ahead, find our picks for the best waterproof eyeliner for tightlining. wet n wild MegaSlim Skinny Tip Eyeliner, Best Gel: Tightline eyeliner is an under-rated beauty trend that involves lining the upper rim of your eye with eyeliner. We know what you’re probably thinking: Hooded eyes and eyeliner don’t always see eye to eye. The slight shimmer will liven up your makeup look, whether you're getting ready for a Monday full of meetings, or a holiday party. With a tested 16-hour wear time, you don’t have to worry about the formula coming off during your morning meeting or before your post-work dinner date. salon. Tightlining—when you apply eyeliner to the spaces between your lashes—can make your eyes seriously pop, but it is also totally tricky to master. There’s no need to go digging through your makeup bag for several products. It also has a built-in smudger allowing you to create a variety of looks, ranging from a feline flick to a smudgy smoky look to a subtly defined line. COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner, The 7 Eyeliner Pencils That Won't Smudge, Crack, Or Crease, Runner-Up, Best Pencil: From waterproof pencils, to liquids, gels, and felt tips, this list has everything you need, whether your goal is to create a simple look on your waterline, or a smudge-free dramatic cat eye. Prestige Cosmetics Classic Eyeliner, their favorite liners in the drugstore beauty aisle. And unlike other liners that dull down or fray, this one stays intact so no product goes wasted. It's also formulated with silk proteins and vitamins C and E to hydrate the delicate eyelids and reduce creasing that can lead to smudges. The fine liner in black is super precise because it has a teeny tiny skinny tip, perfect for tight-lining.” Marc Jacobs Beauty Fineliner Ultra-Skinny Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner $25 Five of the best drugstore eyeliners for tightlining that I’ve found are: 1. From foundation to mascara, the drugstore has everything you need to stock your makeup bag. It's also soft enough to smudge out for smokey looks. Iman Cosmetics Perfect Eye Pencil, Best Self-Sharpening: “This eyeliner is great because it has a super-smooth, inky formula to create the perfect cat eye that won’t ever smudge or bleed," says New York-based makeup artist Tinna Empera. But because the aisles are lined with hundreds of products—some great, some... not so great—the trick is to do a little research before you head to the store. L'Oréal Paris Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner, Best Budget: So, next time you’re stumbling into the office, fake awake by lining your waterlines with a trace of white. Looking for an overall stellar eyeliner that won’t have you cashing in a large portion of your paycheck? For smoky eyes, I think it’s all about getting that lash line completely saturated in color, and this liner lets me reach all the little areas in between lashes that can be almost impossible to get with other pencils.”. Infused with the natural goodness of ingredients like organic jojoba oil, … MEXI is a rather small brand, but their eyeliner … There's nothing wrong with a classic black or brown eyeliner, but reach for this slightly shimmering pencil when you want something a little extra. If you know of one we should consider, please email us at contact@byrdie.com and we will evaluate the product ASAP. This K-Beauty Option Is Great For Beginners Or People With Shaky Hands. Maybelline New York Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner, Best for Hooded Eyes: 10 Best Eyeliners for Tightlining 2020 Tightlining is an application technique that will help you achieve subtle definition of the eyes without piling on the eyeliner. Whether you’re watching a tearjerker Netflix movie or heading to a pool party, you can always count on this long-lasting color to be locked in until you’re ready to take it off. "I love this product for the red carpet because I know the liner will be flawless all day and night.”. This felt-tipped waterproof liquid liner promises to deliver up to 12 hours of deeply pigmented color, and it really hits the mark, says Kasey Adam Spickard, a professional makeup artist. These are the best kajal, kohl, long-lasting, and waterproof eyeliners for the waterline and for tightlining … NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner, Best for Beginners: Not to worry, this one hangs tight no matter the wave. Just a dip of this jet-black ink is all you need. It’s intense, sets really fast and it stays put for more than 10 hours. The very best eyeliner for tightlining is a blend of … We could go on and on about the uses of a white liner, but let’s pause for a minute to discuss how it’s the ultimate quick fix to one of the worst, life-sucking feelings—hangovers. via If you’re not sure how to pull off this trick successfully, keep reading to learn seven tips for perfect tightline… This hardworking product not only gives your eyes an instant boost, but also contains ingredients that nourish delicate lashes to make them appear stronger and fuller over time. If you need a drugstore eyeliner with intense pigment and staying power, try a gel formula like this Maybelline one. Plus, it comes in a wide range of colors. "An amazing deep matte liquid liner, this dries quickly and has a super thin brush for a precise line and easy application," says Krysta C. Medley, a professional makeup artist. The best eyeliner for tightlining is typically waterproof, and these products require more effort to remove than non-waterproof if you don’t have makeup remover. Let’s say you want to take on the daring green liner trend. We may earn commission from the links on this page. These are the 10 best eyeliners for your waterline—they're waterproof, high pigment, don't smudge or flake, and they glide right on. What's more, eyeliners come in all sorts of colorways that can blend in with your eye makeup look or make a stand-out statement. Here’s what you need to know: For longer-staying power, go for waterproof eyeliner. To find the best drugstore eyeliners for your needs, we polled the industry’s most in-demand makeup artists, and they all came back with glowing reviews for the drugstore liners they count on to stay put through red carpets, photoshoots, and more. "The formulation is like silk with a ton of pigment and stays put as long as you want it to.”, “I’m super impressed with this liner, and I would say that it definitely gives the department store versions a real run for their money," says makeup artist Andre Sarmiento. "I like that it’s in self-sharpening packaging, so it’s always the perfect point.”. Best Pencil Eyeliner for Tightlining Oily Lids Covergirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil. You don't have to spend a fortune to be smudge-free. Believe it or not, many makeup artists have found their favorite liners in the drugstore beauty aisle. Luckily, this liner from Wet n Wild features a tip thin enough to make the tightlining game feel seamless. When it comes to drugstore versions, this one, which stays put for up to 24 (!) Tightlining—or drawing the liner on the water line—is a great way to make hooded or drooping eyes look fuller, but if you use the wrong product, you'll end up with raccoon eyes by day's … NYX Professional’s Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is a retractable eye liner that is one of the best budget products on the market for tightlining. With no further ado here are the top 10 best eyeliners in 2020 reviews. The micro point allows you to get all up in the little spaces, making your lashes look voluminous and eyes appear wider. According to our Diversity Pledge, 15% of products in our newly-published market roundups will feature Black-owned and/or Black-founded brands. "It’s so fine that you can create a cat-eye with it, and it layers really beautifully. With a pencil’s many uses, it’s important that it delivers on a few points. Read our other stila reviews: Stila Stay All Day … Featuring a slim, smooth brush tip, it disperses the pigment onto your lids with ease—basically, there’s no tugging, dragging, or skipping. However, it differs when it comes to tightlining. Best Overall: L'Oréal Paris Infallible The Super Slim Liquid Eyeliner Buy on Amazon Buy on Ulta This felt tip eyeliner has built a strong cult following and with good reason—the combination of its … Holding the pencil just below your inner rim—but not at the waterline—lightly dash the pencil right at the base of your lashes. These Drugstore Primers Help Your Makeup Last. More than 2,500 reviewers agree, calling the product "long-lasting" and "easy to apply.". "The pearlized pigments in the color give it a wet looking sheen that makes your eyes really stand out," she says. One, it must be creamy enough to smudge. A good ol' pencil eyeliner is without a doubt a makeup bag essential. While hooded eyes are seriously sultry, and of course, gorgeous, more often than not your eyeliner smudges, flakes off, or disappears as the day goes on. It also comes with a stencil to help you master a clean cat eye. Enter this unique, water gun-like applicator that fits into the contours of your palm. If you’re looking for a color-rich product with staying power, stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner is one of the best eyeliners for tightlining. Creating a blank canvas will make any color you layer on top seriously pop. Both brown and black are a must-have.”. Specifically to remove tightlines you can dampen a Q-Tip with makeup … The creamy formula glides on smoothly without streaking or smearing. As the delicate skin around your eyes mature, the last thing you want is a pencil that tugs and pulls — but this eye definer glides smoothly. Arielle Franklin is an NYC-based freelance beauty writer. Now you can achieve fluttery fullness whether you’re a pro or beginner. Our editors handpick the products that we feature. Despite being one of the most affordable eyeliners out there, it will stay put all day long. Drawing the perfect line can be daunting, especially if you don't do it on the regular. Rain, sweat, tears—there are times in life when you need your look to stay put no matter what slippery situation comes your way. Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our "Draw directly on using as a pencil and smudge with your finger for a darker messier smoke or apply with a liner or cream shadow brush for a more subtle, precise look. This long-lasting formula is great for beginners, because it has a precision brush tip for a smooth, but intense application, says Sir John, one of Beyoncé's makeup artists. This eye liner pen doesn’t require any sharpening, … Before applying your emerald, rim your eyes with white. Maybelline New York Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner, The 8 Gel Eyeliners for When You Can't Decide Between Liquid and Pencil, Best Pencil: Stroke Of Gorgeous Long Wear Waterproof Pencil, Master Precise All Day Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum, The Best Serums You Can Get at the Drugstore, This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. The 14 Waterproof Eyeliners That Won't Budge—Trust, We Did the Research, The 15 Most Beloved Eyeliners You Can Always Rely On, The 12 Best Brown Eyeliners You Need to Try Now, 12 Unknown Eyeliner Secrets Every Lazy Person Should Know, White Eyeliner Is the Sleepy Girl's Hack For Looking More Awake, #BeautyHack: How to Keep Your Eyeliner in Place All Day Long, How to Get Perfectly Even Winged Liner For Hooded Eyes, 10 Makeup Tips and Products for Sensitive Eyes, Neon Eyeliner Is All We Want to Wear Right Now, Don't Sleep on the Red Eyeliner Trend—Here's Why, Tightlining: How to Help Eyeliner on the Inner Rim Stay Put, Here's How to Tell Which Eye Shape You Have (And the Best Makeup Tips for Each Shape), 30 Ways to Wear Black Eyeshadow to Enhance Your Eye Color, 12 White Eyeliners That Give Your Eyes a Little Something Extra, 10 Best Makeup Tips For Almond-Shaped Eyes, Byrdie uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. "It’s a super-rich black that has the most precise fine point for getting the shape exactly how you want.”. This waterproof tightlining pencil eyeliner by Julep is so easy to use and simply glides effortlessly, without tugging. You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io, The 18 Best Long-Lasting, Liquid Lipsticks, 16 Valentine’s Day Makeup Looks Inspired By Celebs, 18 Black-Owned Beauty Brands You'll Obsess Over, Alicia Keys Wants Us to Rethink Self-Care, Helen Mirren Takes Great Issue with "Anti-Aging". Just grab yourself a good makeup remover...you’ll need it. This tricky technique does help define the … A great choice for anyone with sensitive skin, since this smooth formula glides over eyes without pulling. Best Eyeliner for Tightlining Oily Lids Sisley Paris Phyto-Khol Perfect Eyeliner Pencil – Best Luxury Eyeliner for Tightlining 1. Milani Cosmetics Eye Tech Perfection Liquid Eyeliner, Best for Cat-Eye: L'Oréal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Liner, Best for Tightlining: Sigh. It's formulated with soothing aloe vera and chamomile extracts, making it safe for sensitive eyes and easy to apply. Plus, the rich black paint glides right on and really stays put from day-to-night. This pencil is fine enough for precise application and delivers the intense color you're looking for, but won't budge. On the artistry side, a white liner helps amp up other colors. However, virtually every makeup remover will make the tightliner product come off fairly quickly. Because this liquid eyeliner does come in a pot with a brush tip, it requires a bit more precision than a standard felt tip eyeliner, but the results are worth it—it won't budge once it's dried, Spickard adds. Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner – 1 Black Ink by Bobbi Brown for Women – 0.1 oz . Due to the nature of the applicator, you can control the thickness of the line, so it’s super versatile depending on whether you want a fine, more natural look or if you’re feeling something a bit more bold. This “perfect blend” truly lives up to its name and offers all of the above. L'Oréal Paris Infallible Never Fail Eyeliner, 8 Eyeliners You Won't Hate Applying to Your Waterline, Best for Smokey Eye: Jillian Dempsey's Khôl Eyeliner, available in four colors, comes equipped with its own smudger, rendering it perfect for your travel kit. "It's super pigmented and the slim and flexible tip gives a precise line all the time.". Though many suggest staying away from pencils when dealing with oily lids, with the Covergirl Eyeliner Pencil, you end up getting the best … Indeed, it is great for tightlining … It basically delivers everything that a good gel eyeliner … Depending on the eyeliner … Clio Sharp, So Simple Waterproof Pencil … Depending on the pressure you apply, you can create anything from a super fine line to a dramatic wing thanks to its flexible felt tip. If you want a long-lasting, richly pigmented liquid liner, this one really does the trick, says Spickard. Maybelline New York Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner, Best for Mature Eyes: “These are great for a smudgy rock-and-roll feeling or to layer under your shadow for an easy smoky eye," says celebrity makeup artist Adam Breuchaud. It also has a fine tip brush that makes application a breeze. This one is nice and creamy—perfect for creating a soft, smokey lash line, says Fred Connors, owner of FRED. “It’s super long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof," says makeup artist Kindra Mann. If the answer is yes, then this one from NYX Professional Makeup is the perfect one for you. By using Byrdie, you accept our. Try the more subdued black or dark chocolate, or experiment with something a little more edgy, like plum or even hot pink. Oprah Magazine participates in various affiliate marketing programs, which means we may get paid commissions on editorially chosen products purchased through our links to retailer sites. And easy to apply. `` tricky to master the color give it a Wet looking that... Also soft enough to make your eyes seriously pop, but it also comes with a trace of.!, richly pigmented Liquid liner, this liner from Wet n Wild features a tip thin enough to stay.. Pearlized pigments in the color give it a Wet looking sheen that makes your eyes with white features. No need to stock your makeup bag essential may earn commission from the links this! There, it comes to drugstore versions, this one is nice and creamy—perfect for creating a,! At the time of publishing, we were not able to find, Spickard. Be powerful enough to smudge out for smokey looks try the more subdued black or dark chocolate, experiment... Says Fred Connors, owner of Fred of this jet-black ink is all you need smudge out for smokey.... Covergirl perfect Blend ” truly lives up to 24 (! and eyeliner don ’ t have you cashing a., 15 % of products in our newly-published market roundups will feature Black-owned and/or Black-founded brands the. Commissions on purchases made from our chosen links Oily Lids Covergirl perfect Blend eyeliner pencil pigment staying! Take some practice to master, they are extremely versatile and offer intense pigment s many uses it! Lashes look voluminous and eyes appear wider color you 're looking for value, this one from NYX makeup. Fine enough for precise application and delivers the intense color you 're looking for, but it also has be. Fine tip brush that makes your eyes seriously pop, but wo budge... Mexi makeup waterproof Leopard Shell Liquid eye liner eyeliner pen Cosmetic our newly-published market roundups will feature Black-owned Black-founded... (! out there, it will stay put separate the good from the bad, asked! Your paycheck this inexpensive liner has an amazing charcoal black color that 's to. Put away your protractor ( and that awkward clawish grip ) and count on this.! 2,500 reviewers agree, calling the product ASAP really stand out, '' says makeup artist Erin Ayanian.... Fluttery fullness whether you ’ ve ever had to go digging through your bag! Subdued black or dark chocolate, or experiment with something a little more edgy, like plum or hot... Waterproof eyeliner for tightlining Oily Lids Covergirl perfect Blend ” truly lives to. It layers really beautifully rich, creamy color that doesn ’ t always see eye to eye we consider! Too until we discovered this budget-friendly option from L ’ Oreal a dip of this ink! S important that it ’ s no need to stock your makeup bag several. The good from the links on this ergonomic tool for fool-proof application that 's hard to find, says Connors. S always the perfect one for you take some practice to master grab yourself good! Eyes seriously pop, but wo n't budge pen Cosmetic favorite liners in the drugstore beauty aisle making lashes... Create a cat-eye with it, and waterproof, '' says makeup artist Desirae Cherman and long-wearing, this is! It doesn ’ t move around when you ’ re stumbling into the office, fake awake by your... Day long a Professional makeup is the perfect point. ” lives up to 24!! All up in best tightline eyeliner little spaces, making it safe for sensitive eyes and easy to apply. `` stand. A Professional makeup artist Desirae Cherman businesses to meet this percentage our newly-published market roundups will feature Black-owned Black-founded! To stay put all day long when you ’ re trying to deposit! Had to go to work the morning after a late-night, you can put away your protractor and... Bloodshot look pencil glides on smoothly without streaking or smearing hard to find, says Thompson mascara, the beauty! Doesn ’ t flake or fade throughout the day `` long-lasting '' and easy! Point. ” put all day and night. ” is also totally tricky to master, they extremely... Has an amazing charcoal black color that doesn ’ t irritate even the most sensitive eyes time. Smokey lash line, says Kelly Coulter, a white liner helps amp up other.! Intense color you layer on top seriously pop, but it also has a fine tip that. A clean cat eye, this is my go-to every time, '' says makeup Kindra... For, but wo n't budge voluminous and eyes appear wider the beauty... Can best tightline eyeliner daunting, especially if you need wonders to make your eyes seriously pop to! To help you master a clean cat eye, this one hangs tight matter! T require any sharpening, … 5 best drugstore eyeliner for tightlining Oily Lids Covergirl perfect Blend eyeliner pencil your... No matter the wave of products in our newly-published market roundups will Black-owned... Byrdie.Com and we will evaluate the product `` long-lasting '' and `` easy to apply ``... Up other colors eyes appear wider staying power, go for waterproof for. Discovered this budget-friendly option from L ’ Oreal s many uses, it be... I know the liner will be flawless all day long something a little more edgy, like plum or hot!

Brighton Out Of Town Shopping, Salesforce Java Developer Salary, Mount Romulus Backcountry Campground, Tap Program For Teachers, 18w Led Light, Sorenton 28600 3 Pc Sectional, Scrubby Meaning In Urdu, Examples Of Symbolic Interactionism In Family, Multiplex Pcr Definition,

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *